Skip to Content

How to Reheat Steak without Making it Dry and Losing the Taste

After a hearty dinner, we will surely have many leftovers, especially the steak. You wonder how to reheat steak the right way? Because our goal is to want the steak after reheating to be tender and juicy. Let’s find out via the article. 

How to reheat steak the right way?

Depending upon the thickness of the steak, you will choose the best way to warm up the steak. You can reheat steak using the microwave or the stovetop. You can also combine both devices when reheating.

1. Reheat steak in the microwave

how to reheat steak battersby 1

Microwave method

Reheating steak in the microwave should be a last resort when you’re having a hard time, but it can be done. And the trick is to save the juices from cooked steaks the night before. You will store them in a freezer bag or airtight container with leftover steaks in the fridge. 

When you’re ready to warm your steaks. Pour the juices over after placing them in a microwave-safe dish.

If you can’t save juice, you can also use a small amount of steak sauce, Italian sauce, or thin gravy instead. Cover the dish with cling film to keep it moist. 

Switch the heat to low or medium and cook for 30 seconds. Constantly checking for the proper temperature. Reheating steaks in the microwave will quickly dry out your delicious steaks. If you left reheated steak in there for too long.

2. Reheat steak in the stovetop

how to reheat steak battersby 2

How to reheat steak: Stovetop method

We’ve found that cooking steak on the stovetop is a great way to preserve the meat on the outside. Place the steak in a skillet with a teaspoon of oil over medium-low heat and cover the pan for a few seconds to allow heat to circulate throughout the meat. 

In a pan over medium heat, put a tablespoon of olive oil. You need to add your steak as well as flip every minute until you get your desired one. This process takes only 2 to 3 minutes for medium-rare.

You need to remember that with the microwave, cooking steak too quickly and at too high of a temperature will dry out the steak.

With this method, it’s best to let go of the expectation that your steak will always be as fresh and juicy as it was in the first place. To get the most out of a previously cooked steak, chop it up into bite-sized pieces and add it to new recipes.

3. Reheat steak: Oven-to-stovetop

how to reheat steak battersby 3

Put the steak in the oven for about 20-30 minutes first before moving to the stovetop

A way to maintain a juicy steak is to reheat it slowly in the oven first. Then finish on the stove. 

Start by setting your oven to 250°F. This low temperature will retain the juices of your steak. Take a shallow baking sheet and place a stable cooling wire rack inside it. Cooking steaks on a cooling wire rack allows hot air to circulate around the steak better, giving you a more evenly heated steak.

Place steak on a wire rack and place in the oven for about 20-30 minutes. Until the internal temperature reaches about 100-110 degrees Fahrenheit.

Next, pour a tablespoon of vegetable oil into a medium cast iron skillet. Place on the stove over medium-high heat. Place your steak in the frying pan when the oil is almost smoking. Let the steaks cook for about 60 seconds on each side. It is enough time to get a crispy exterior. Let rest 5-10 before slicing.

4. Additional method: Add some beef broth

Planning to use a pan to reheat steaks? We may have a hack for you. Adding some beef broth to the pan just before you add the meat might be the answer. You don’t need to use any oil as long as your pan isn’t sticky!

Let the broth heat for a minute or two so it starts to bubble up a bit. Next, add the meat and watch until the meat is cooked beautifully. It will only take a minute! 

The broth’s secret ingredient gives the meat extra moisture. This will prevent the steak from drying out or going rubbery. Nothing could be better! 

Tips for perfectly reheat steak without drying it out

how to reheat steak battersby 4

How to reheat steak: Useful tips for a tender steak

Don’t reheat your steak as soon as you take it out of the fridge. Let it sit out for about 30 minutes. That will make it come to room temperature. This will make the steak less likely to overcook. It is an easy way to increase your chances of a successful reheating experience.

If you’re trying to cook a steak that you know you probably won’t be able to, purposefully cook it for a minute. Cook for about three minutes on each side for a beautifully cooked steak. That your reheater of choice won’t overcook the next day.

How to store fresh and leftover steak

For raw and unopened steaks, be sure to refrigerate in their original packaging until you’re ready to use. However, if there is a gap in the package where air can enter, be sure to place the steak in an airtight glass container.

If you want to prolong its life, put the raw steak in the freezer. Be sure to cover the original packaging with cling film, aluminum foil, or paper towel. It will prevent the freezer from burning.

If stored properly, raw steak will retain its quality and flavor for about 6 to 12 months. For cooked steaks, refrigerate in an airtight container. Or you can use cling film or aluminum foil to cover tightly. It should easily last for about 3 to 4 days in your refrigerator, if stored properly.

To extend shelf life even further, be sure to freeze cooked steaks. Place in a freezer bag or alternative. Then keep it in the freezer. If stored properly, it will retain its flavor and quality for about 2 to 3 months.

How about trying cold leftover steak?

how to reheat steak

Serving the leftover steak cold to reserve the flavor

In fact, if you find all the methods of reheating leftover steak are complicated. As simple methods (like the microwave) are likely to overcook your steak. Leaving it both dry and chewy.

Fortunately, there’s a very easy way to cook leftover steak while preserving the delicious flavor you’ve worked so hard for. And it’s easier than any other reheating method: Serve it cold!

Thinly sliced, cold steak makes a great topping on salads. Or, place it between bread, along with tomatoes, mayo, and lettuce to make a steak sandwich. 

It’s also delicious simply sliced and eaten cold or room temperature along with yesterday’s reheated steak sides. So before proceeding, consider if just eating it in the fridge will work and give it a try.

Conclusion

So, how to reheat steak but still keep it juicy? Depending on your needs, you have a lot of methods to choose from. Follow the ways that Battersby has instructed you. And you will have the most delicious and hot steak.