Skip to Content

How To Reheat Stuffed Peppers? 3 Methods Of Reheating Stuffed Peppers

Stuffed peppers are one of the most favorite dishes of many people. It is a bell pepper stuffed with ground beef, tomato sauce, vegetables, olive oil, and many other delicious ingredients.

Many recipes involve stuffed peppers. It is very healthy and delicious. However, it would be best if you focused on properly reheating frozen stuffed peppers.

So, how to reheat frozen stuffed peppers?

Using the oven, microwave oven, and air fryer are the three best ways for reheating stuffed peppers. The best method to reheat stuffed pepper is using an oven. It avoids soggy stuffed peppers.

Let’s dive into each detailed method with Battersby!

how to reheat stuffed peppers

There are three ways to reheat your stuffed peppers  

How To Reheat Stuffed Peppers in the Oven?

The best way to reheat stuffed pepper is using an oven.

Step 1: Prepare Oven

Preheat the oven at 175°C. It is the most suitable heat zone. This temperature helps the peppers ripen to the core without scorching the skin.

Step 2: Place Frozen Peppers on a Plate and Cover

You need to put the frozen stuffed peppers on the oven-proof dish and close the lid. Or you can also use aluminum foil to cover.

Please note that you need to place the stuffing of leftover stuffed peppers facing up. This way helps to keep the fresh juices from meat and spices from flowing out.

In addition, it is better to arrange by a single layer. Never stack leftover stuffed peppers on top of each other, as this will damage the bottom stuffing.

Covering leftover stuffed peppers helps maintain and evenly distribute the temperature. It also avoids drying out the stuffed peppers. If you don’t have a heat-resistant lid, just wrapping foil is enough.

Step 3: Reheat Frozen Stuffed Peppers for 45 Mins

With the freshly prepared stuffed peppers, you only need to oven reheat for 15 minutes on the baking dish. However, you need to cook 45 minutes for frozen stuffed peppers.

Similarly, you only need to cook the 15-minute baking recipe for defrosted stuffed peppers.

Step 4: Remove the Lid and Cook for a Further 5 Mins

After 45 minutes, the stuffed bell peppers are hot and starting to evaporate. It is better to remove the foil or cover and continue to bake for 5 mins more.

The process of toasting the head is for doneness. The following 5 minutes of baking is for the stuffed to turn golden and crispy.

Step 5: Finish and Enjoy

You’ll need to double-check to make sure all the stuffed peppers are “cooked.” It’s essential when you’re reheating frozen peppers, seafood or meat fillings. 

Now you have delicious stuffed peppers. Take the cooked peppers out of the oven and serve them with your side dish.

how to reheat stuffed peppers battersby 2

Reheating stuffing with an oven is the best way 

Method To Reheat Stuffed Peppers in Air Fryer

Reheating stuffed pepper with an air fryer is a suitable method. It saves time compared to the oven and avoids broken texture like when using the microwave.

Instead of having to defrost in advance, you can reheat as soon as you take the stuffed peppers out of the freezer.

how to reheat stuffed peppers battersby 3

Stuffed red peppers

Step 1: Put the Stuffed Peppers Into the Air Fryer.

Slowly place the stuffed peppers into the air fryer basket. Spray a little cooking oil on the tray to prevent it from sticking and save cleaning time. Similar to the above two ways, please arrange only one layer on the tray.

In an air fryer, air circulates in every nook and cranny to cook the food. Therefore, do not put leftover stuffed peppers too close together.

Step 2: Reheat in the Air Fryer (350°F – 5 Mins)

Preheat the leftover stuffed peppers air fryer for 5 mins at 350°F.

  • Chilled stuffed peppers: 5 mins
  • Frozen stuffed peppers: 15 mins

Step 3: Finish and Enjoy.

Before finishing, carefully check once again that they are piping hot. You should check if you reheat beef stuffed peppers. Meaty stuffed peppers take longer to cook than vegetables.

Remove reheated stuffed peppers from the air fryer and eat while still hot.

How To Cook Frozen Stuffed Peppers In The Microwave?

Using a microwave to reheat your stuffed peppers is an easy and quick way. If you don’t have time, then choose this way.

However, microwave reheating is not as good as oven reheating. It will break the structure of stuffed pepper. And your stuffed peppers will become watery and mushy. However, it’s not too big of a deal when you’re busy.

The important thing is that it only takes you a few minutes to have hot stuffed chili to eat.

With an oven, you don’t need to defrost frozen stuffed peppers. But if using a microwave, you need to defrost them thoroughly before putting them in the microwave.

Another way is to turn on the defrost mode first. Then move on to the heating process.

how to reheat stuffed peppers battersby 4

Stuffed peppers with a microwave

Step 1: Put Stuffed Peppers Into the Microwave.

Put the leftover stuffed peppers into a microwave-safe plate or a microwave-safe dish. Please note that the plate or container must be microwave-safe.

It would be best to place the stuffing side facing up so that the juicy doesn’t spill out. Besides, it’s terrible to stack stuffed bell peppers on top because it will flatten the bottom piece.

Step 2: Microwave Reheat for 2 Mins on Full Power.

Place peppers dish in the microwave. Turn power and reheat stuffing for 2 mins.

Step 3: Check if You Need to Heat Again.

Check if the stuffed peppers are completely piping hot. If you are not sure, you can continue cooking for another 15 seconds. Just 15 seconds, or you’ll have mushy bell peppers and overcook.

Step 4: Enjoy.

Use heat-resistant gloves to remove the disc or container from the microwave. You can save effort by placing each stuffed pepper on a separate plate. Then enjoy right out of the microwave.

How Long To Cook Frozen Stuffed Peppers?

The cooking times of frozen stuffed pepper depend on the reheating methods.

  • Reheat in the oven: 45 minutes for frozen stuffed peppers and 45 minutes for defrosted stuffed peppers. That thawing in the fridge overnight helps you save time.
  • Reheat in the microwave: about 2 mins
  • Reheat in the air fryer: 350°F – 5 mins

how to reheat stuffed peppers battersby 5

It doesn’t take long to reheat stuffed peppers 

How Can I Freeze Stuffed Peppers?

Yes. You can freeze stuffed peppers to preserve them longer. It is better to let stuffed peppers cool completely. Then wrap each stuffed pepper in plastic wrap. Covering another layer of foil outside would be better.

Put the pre-wrapped stuffed peppers in an airtight container or a freezer bag and store them in the freezer.

Alternatively, you can also freeze uncooked stuffed peppers using the same method. This way, you have stuffed peppers in reserve for three months.

You should vacuum the airtight container or suck the air out as much as possible. Don’t coat the cheese before you’re about to eat stuffing.

Freezing stuffed peppers also helps stuffed peppers become slightly softer. You’ll even see more juicy juices coming out than you’re processing right away.

You can watch this video for more information. 

Final Thoughts

Above are three ways to reheat stuffed peppers at home. Let’s go to the kitchen and cook a delicious meal for your family. Feel free to contact Battersby if you get any troubles with the recipe. Thank you for reading!