Skip to Content

Can You Make Peanut Butter Cookies Without Brown Sugar?

Who doesn’t like a freshly baked batch of homemade peanut butter cookies? It’s a fantastic dish to try for any sweet tooth. However, can you make easy peanut butter cookies without brown sugar if you don’t have brown sugar at home?

You may bake cookies entirely out of white sugar or any other substitute for brown sugar. Yes, it is true, and all these cookies are delicious but a bit less chewy than typical brown sugar peanut cookies.

So, let’s discover our peanut butter cookie recipe with no brown sugar!

How Do Peanut Butter Cookies With And Without Brown Sugar Differ?

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar

Peanut Butter Cookies

Dark chocolate chips or traditional peanut butter cookies are standard, but you can make peanut butter cookies in various ways. For somewhat varied outcomes, try varying the components, changing the amounts, or leaving some out. 

Depending on your substitute or modified components, you may make crispier, thinner, or chewier, fluffier cookies. Different kinds of flour might result in a completely different cookie. 

For making cookies, softening or melting your butter may make a big difference. According to your preferences, you may also add multiple nuts or less and more chocolate chips. 

Although the most incredible chocolate chip cookies contain a substantial quantity of chocolate, one entire 12-ounce bag or 2 cups is often calculated. Any recipe for peanut butter chips usually includes some necessary components like sugar and butter. 

Brown sugar is among the most common ingredients in this sort of dish. Is it, nevertheless, a requirement for chunky peanut butter cookies to turn out properly? Will it make a significant difference in the flavor or texture of your cookies? 

Difference Between White Sugar And Brown Sugar

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar battersby 2

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Brown sugar is white sugar that has been combined with molasses to give it a brown hue. Molasses is a syrup made from white sugar. It seems to have a caramel taste that complements a variety of savory and sweet recipes. 

The molasses combine with white sugar in brown sugar, which holds moisture better than pure cane sugar. Brown and white sugar have nutritional profiles that are just slightly different. 

Although brown sugar has fewer nutrition calories than white sugar, it is sufficient to be healthier or low-calorie. Brown and white sugar, on the other hand, have distinct acidity and chemistry, and they might act differently based on the recipe.

If you substitute one for another, your recipe’s taste and texture may be affected. Brown sugar may make your biscuits moisture, while white sugar may make them rise more. 

In general, they can make sweet and tasty cookies; it is just a question of taste. There’s a distinction between dark and light brown sugar as well. Dark brown sugar has a higher molasses content, giving it a caramel-like taste.

Can You Make Peanut Butter Cookies Without Brown Sugar?

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar battersby 3

You Can Use White Sugar To Make Peanut Butter Cookies

So, what to do if you do not have brown sugar? You can make peanut butter or chocolate chip cookies entirely out of white sugar or any other substitute for brown sugar. 

All these cookies are delicious but a bit less chewy than typical brown sugar peanut cookies. These cookies are crispy and sweet for all those crunchy cookie fans out there!

7 Substitutes For Brown Sugar

There are few things more frustrating than finding you’ve run out of brown sugar through a baking recipe for the ideal peanut butter cookies. However, you may use several practical alternatives in a crisis, most of which you already have on hand. 

Here are seven creative brown sugar alternatives.

White Sugar With Molasses

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar battersby 4Molasses

Brown sugar may be substituted with a mixture of molasses and white sugar. Combine 1 cup granulated sugar with 1 tbsp molasses to produce your homemade brown sugar. Add the molasses to two tablespoons if you require dark brown sugar. So now you’ve got brown sugar.

White Sugar With Maple Syrup

If you do not have molasses, you may substitute maple syrup with white sugar. There is practically no difference in the result of your dish. 

Combine one cup of granulated white sugar plus one tablespoon pure maple syrup to form a brown sugar replacement that will deceive even the most discerning palate.

Coconut Sugar

You can use coconut tree sap to make coconut sugar. It is frequently advertised as a healthy sugar substitute since it includes minerals, vitamins, and fiber that are not present in refined sugar. 

With a 1:1 ratio, coconut and brown sugar may swap together. Although coconut sugar resembles brown sugar in appearance and flavor, it does not contain as much water. This way may change the texture of some baked items, making them somewhat drier or thicker than desired. 

Add a little more fat, such as oil or butter, to your traditional recipe to enhance the moisture levels. You may also use a burner to melt the sugar before incorporating it into the recipe.

Honey, Agave Nectar, Or Maple Syrup

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar battersby 5

Agave Nectar

Honey, agave nectar or maple syrup can all form as a brown sugar substitute with minor changes to the recipe. Since these are liquid substitutes, you will want to consider how the added moisture will influence the outcome of the dish, especially if you’re baking. 

The exact substitute proportions may vary based on the dish, but here are some general guidelines to get you began: 

  • 2/3 cup of liquid sweetener (honey, agave nectar, or maple syrup) for each cup of brown sugar. 
  • Decrease other liquid supplies by about 1/4 cup per each 2/3 cup of liquid sweetener used.

You also wish to shorten the cooking process by some minutes because these sugar substitutes caramelize faster than brown sugar.

Raw Sugar

Raw sugars such as demerara or turbinado work well as brown sugar replacements because of their inherent pale amber hues and light caramel tastes. For most recipes, you can replace brown sugar with raw sugar in an equal quantity and not notice a difference and vice versa. 

On the other hand, Raw sugars are drier and coarser than brown sugar, which affects the outcome of your dish. 

Raw sugar grains do not usually mix into batter or dough as evenly as brown sugar, leaving a gritty texture. It’s especially valid for baked items with low humidity or those with a delicate texture.

If you have got a pestle and mortar or a pepper grinder, you may crush the sugar crystals into a smaller texture that blends better into your dish.

While adding the sugar crystals to the mixture, you may partially dissolve them in a bit of stagnant water, such as oil, melted butter, or water.

Muscovado Sugar

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar battersby 6

Some Types Of Sugar

Muscovado sugar is a slightly processed sugar that works well as a brown sugar alternative since it includes molasses, just like conventional brown sugar.  

Muscovado has significantly greater moisture and molasses content than regular brown sugar. It becomes stickier and more prone to clumping as a result. 

In nearly any preparation, muscovado may replace brown sugar. However, if you are baking with it, sift it to eliminate clumps before incorporating it into your batter or regular peanut butter cookie dough. 

To optimize the incorporation of the muscovado into the recipe, you may use an immersion blender and pour a bit.

White Sugar

You may use an even amount of white sugar in replacement of brown sugar without spoiling the recipe. White sugar doesn’t have the same depth of taste as brown sugar, but based on the dish, you might not feel much of a difference. 

The texture is one area where you can detect a change. Brown sugar gives some baked items, such as cookies, a rich chewiness. Once brown sugar is replaced with white sugar, the outcome may be crispier. It is not always a negative thing, though.

The Best Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe Without Brown Sugar

peanut butter cookies without brown sugar battersby 7

Crunchy Peanut Butter Cookies

To make a delicious peanut butter cookie dish, all you have to do is follow our steps. This dish is one of the best peanut butter cookie recipes without brown sugar that uses white sugar.

You can rely on the instructions in this video to better understand how to make peanut butter cookies no brown sugar.

Ingredients:

  • 1 cup  creamy peanut butter  
  • 1/2 gallon of milk 
  • 1 pound of white sugar 
  • An egg 
  • 1/2 cup of almond flour (all-purpose)  
  • One tbsp powdered sugar 
  • A sprinkle of sea salt
  • Baking soda or baking powder

Procedure:

  • Reheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. 
  • Combine the milk, natural peanut butter, and sugar for two minutes on high speed with an electric mixer. Stir in the egg thoroughly for a minute. 
  • Combine the baking powder or baking soda and almond flour in a separate medium bowl and stir into the preceding mixture. Mix everything until it’s completely smooth. 
  • Form tiny balls using your fingers or an ice scoop, then delicately flatten the tops with a spoon. Put on a baking parchment paper or silicone prepared baking sheet. 
  • Cook for ten minutes, or until gently browned. 
  • After removing them from the baking sheet or wire rack, allow cooling to room temperature before serving. You can store peanut butter cookies in an airtight container in the fridge.

Final Thoughts

Hopefully, after reading this article, you can make a delicious dish of the best peanut butter cookies without brown sugar on your own.

If you are still unsatisfied with this recipe, you can refer to Battersby and get more helpful guides. Thank you for reading!